Skip to main content

Evidence the flu shot doesn't work?

Despite no clinical evidence of the effectiveness of the flu shot for those with a compromised immune system, most experts will agree it's not effective. The immune system just can't mount the necessary response to the vaccine to fight off the flu.

On that same note, most experts will also tell you, getting a flu shot will do no harm, so I've always gotten a flu shot, hoping the experts wrong.

Unfortunately this year has almost convinced me of the futility of getting a flu shot.

For the second time this year, I've gotten sick. Both times with the same symptoms, headache, runny nose and sore throat, and both times lasting about the same number of days. [Note: I am feeling somewhat better, but still experiencing some lingering effects.]

Maybe I should have gotten a second shot. Maybe it wasn't even the flu that I contracted, or maybe it was a different strain of the flu. I can't be sure.

What I can be sure of is how much this experience highlights the much greater importance of everyone else getting their flu shot(s), and staying away from others when they are feeling sick, preventing the spread of any germs or viruses, especially to those who do not have the ability to mount a proper defense.

Comments

Gary P said…
Marc, I have multiple myeloma an incurable blood cancer and I have heard the same thing from my doctor. I still take the shot for the can't hurt reason. He recommends that you take Tamiflu( daily during the flu season). I used to do that, but now just take it whenever I start to feel a cold or flu coming on. Because these often turn into infections for me, I will take Zpak antibiotic whenever I start to show a temp 2 to 3 degrees over normal. Seems to work for me, so far. Best Regard / gary@myelomasurvival.com
Alan said…
I wonder if you ever (in your life) had true flu (influenza). I had the flu once in my life and it was pretty obvious it was more than a cold.

Did you have fever and chills? Muscle aches. Without those I suspect you had a common URI for which a flu shot wouldn't be expected to prevent.
Marc said…
Great! An upper respiratory infection. Just what I needed to hear. Particularly since increased infections are one of the symptoms of disease progression. Couple that with abnormal IgA and IgM test results, and the eye infection I had this past October, things certainly don't seem to be improving.

It's still good to know, all those flu shots may not have been in vain.

And thanks for the input Gary. I'm still hesitant to take any sort of medications. I feel the time for that will come soon enough.
Alan said…
I've never heard of an increased risk of URI's (colds) in immunosuppressed people. (correct me if I'm wrong).
Most of the infections in them are bacterial and fungal.

So stop worrying about a cold.
Marc said…
And what then? I'll just have to find something else to worry about! :)
Alan said…
I wonder if you remember one of our early conversations when you were first diagnosed? I along with most doctors never heard of MCL. Based on your blood work we would have assumed you had CLL and I told you people with that diagnosis can live almost forever.

I think you proved me right. Before docs became aware of MCL you would have been lumped in with CLL with it's good prognosis.

I'll bet the people with MCL who have had poor survival are just a tip of the iceberg of the total MCL population. You probably fall in the majority of MCL patients that carry the diagnosis of CLL.

Is that clear?

In any event stop worrying. Life's too short.

(I should talk, I'm the worry wart of all time).
Marc said…
I vaguely remember. Remember, that was a long time ago.

I guess that's why I was initially diagnosed with CLL. I knew that wasn't correct (my immunophenotype didn't confirm CLL), but my original doctor was interested in pursuing any further (HMO). It was only after going to Kaiser and convincing the doctors there, I didn't have CLL did I get a correct diagnosis.

I've just been very lucky, in that my MCL has behaved very indolently. Most do not, as do many with CLL. I just can't help worrying about how much longer my luck can hold out.

In any event, my "cold" seems to have run its course about now. With the exception of a slight runny nose, I'm feeling pretty good.

Popular posts from this blog

My concerns reaffirmed today

When I was first diagnosed with MCL, I pretty much read just about everything I could get my hands on, I attended various conferences, and I talked to anyone who would listen. One of the most important lessons I learned, and which I've mentioned numerous times before was No one cares more about you than you. But in addition to that, I learned to fear the drug Doxorubicin , AKA Adriamycin, Doxil, Hydroxydoxorubicin, or more affectionately the Red Devil. Besides being a deadly chemical, as is the case with most chemotherapy drugs, it is one of the few chemotherapy drugs known to cause permanent heart damage. I even heard Dr. Sandra Horning , a noted Stanford lymphoma specialist, state at the first lymphoma conference I attended in LA, there was no evidence Doxorubicin provided any added benefit to chemotherapy protocols. This was music to my ears, since Doxorubicin is very common in most lymphoma treatment protocols. And even though Dr. Horning has since changed her tune [which my sk...

Bowling: A metaphor on life [sorta]

Over the past 15+ years the game of bowling has changed dramatically. Not only has the equipment changed, making it easier for bowlers of all ages and physical conditions to participate, and score well, but there have even been major advances to how the lanes are prepared for the start of bowling. No longer is it just heavy oil, light oil, long oil, short oil, or no oil, with the latest equipment, the amount of oil can be varied from front to back and side to side, producing a myriad of patterns designed to make the game more interesting, more challenging and as you might surmise, more frustrating. No longer does the "one ball fits all" approach work any more either. In order to navigate all the differing possible lane conditions, you need to have a varied selection of bowling balls. Most pros will tell you the average bowler needs 3 balls, plus a ball for spares, but to be an above average bowler you'll need at least 6 balls, with many possessing more than that. But just...

Fatigue! Part II - Maybe it is real?

Or it's actually Motivational Deficiency Disorder, MoDeD (pronounced Mo-Dee-Dee) for short. In a report this week by Roy Moynihan who reports for the British Medical Journal Austrailian scientists may have come across the reason for extreme laziness . The condition is claimed to affect up to one in five Australians and is characterised by overwhelming and debilitating apathy. Neuroscientists at the University of Newcastle in Australia say that in severe cases motivational deficiency disorder can be fatal, because the condition reduces the motivation to breathe. Neurologist Leth Argos is part of the team that has identified the disorder, which can be diagnosed using a combination of positron emission tomography and low scores on a motivation rating scale, previously validated in elite athletes. "This disorder is poorly understood," Professor Argos told the BMJ. "It is underdiagnosed and undertreated." Who knew? Maybe I have MoDeD, from my attempts to become a...